And totally is not being honest in this post, IMO. He clearly said bad things about David A’s dad in these interviews that do not come across as “he’s nice and all” and the people that are reading this post know that. You don’t try to clean up by contradicting yourself …..doesn’t he know you just admit that you misspoke!

He must have missed the fact that misspoke is the new “I don’t recall”.

So I guess David Cook really did borrow from Doxology? Wow. I’m sorry I doubted their claim now.

He could have said, Oh I don’t recall that, or Gee I didn’t mean to, but instead he pulled forth his reasoning as best as he could in the face of such dismal prospects. Maybe he should have offered an apology, but I think he wanted to explain himself and offer the respect of an opinion well-met.
You can’t address the H8ters, but he at least offered Rickey and the fans acknowledgment and a gentle hand. It shows that you know, he cares.

He’s going to make me cry yet, today. I swear.

So I guess David Cook really did borrow from Doxology? Wow. I’m sorry I doubted their claim now

Good to know because Blake is getting crap for that too. Which that puzzles me, I mean the guy is looking out for his friends who have also been trying to break into the music biz. I did download Doxologys version from i-tunes.

With that I also totally agree with Joyce!

Sorta OT: I didn’t watch AI until Season 4, but I’m betting the internet has really changed this competition.

did hear the “dad” comment and I don’t think he needs to justify anything he said. I read awful stuff about David A’s dad on EW. The haters on Rickey need to get a life. They just want something to yell about.

I agree–what Blake said was a very minor mention in passing. It’s a rock to hurl at our boy, is all.

The Dad thing in general still troubles me, because it is something that won’t go away. If he’s been reported as bullying little David, and Simon almost came right out last night and said David needs to stop letting his Dad pick his songs, there has got to be some truth to this. The Truth of it scares me, and saddens me for that young boy.:-/

What the Archie fans might want to consider is, how they will feel if they find out the rumors are true? If they love little David so much, they might want to look into that. I know I would, were I them and suppose to care so much. Not all young performers are so lucky as to have loving and supporting/protective parents. Stage-parents are a known term for a reason.

And, yeah, they are posting links to his other interviews. I’ll never get the hating. If I don’t care for someone, then I’m sure as hell not going to listen to all their interviews and watch all their appearances so that I can rip them for it. IMO, there is something just a little twisted in that. Why put yourself thru that torture?

I do appreciate the effort he made, but unfortunately, it appears that he’s just feeding the trolls. I do have to wonder if someone twisted his arm to post that. I agree that he really has nothing to apologize for. They got themselves bent out of shape for some random comments.

I did hear the “dad” comment and I don’t think he needs to justify anything he said. I read awful stuff about David A’s dad on EW. The haters on Rickey need to get a life. They just want something to yell about. Blake said nothing wrong IMHO and can give his opinion if he wants. Way too much is being made out of this. I loved B from the beginning because he was original and true to himself and wasn’t molded into the typical contestant. If he wants to speak, I say so be it. Think of all of the trash said about Sanjaya. Blake’s comments are mild by comparison. I’m sure he has a raft of people on his publicity team and is getting the best advice from them. If people become haters because B said David A. is boring (HE IS boring BTW IMO) they were never fans to begin with.

CJ,

I love every word of this post. The “dad” comment came from the DC interview. I just started going back and listening to bits and pieces of the interviews and that’s where it came from. I agree that he was totally justified in what he said as well. As far as the “boring” comment, we all know that was just his opinion. If you really are a fan of Blake’s it really shouldn’t matter whether or not he likes your favorite AI contestant from this year. At least that’s the way I see it. :)

Joyce,

I agree with everyone else, very good post!

I have nothing against this boy, but on the show I was frustrated at his progression.

B speaks the truth. Wasn’t all of America frustrated with how far he was making it on the show?

LOL. N/M.

What the Archie fans might want to consider is, how they will feel if they find out the rumors are true? If they love little David so much, they might want to look into that. I know I would, were I them and suppose to care so much. Not all young performers are so lucky as to have loving and supporting/protective parents. Stage-parents are a known term for a reason.

How true Bully. Some kids break under that pressure and are not really happy. I hope that David is strong and overcomes it, and that he is doing music because he loves it and not because his parents do.

Every time I read a story about this, I think about how supportive Dallas and Dinah have been for Blake. They show their support and love without all the pressure.

So I guess David Cook really did borrow from Doxology? Wow. I’m sorry I doubted their claim now.

I feel sorry for David Cook - if what Blake said is true (and why would he not tell the truth), then David got a bad rep because TPTB cut his comment. Daughtry/Live/I Walk The Line all over again.

He *did* say that he was blown away by his version of “Imagine” but of course people conveniently forget that.

People tend to remember/focus on the negative comments, don’t they?

I feel sorry for David Cook - if what Blake said is true (and why would he not tell the truth), then David got a bad rep because TPTB cut his comment. Daughtry/Live/I Walk The Line all over again.

Bouffe–You’re right! It was TPTB slip-up, and I guess that’s why Seacrest was damm certain to say in introduction last night, who it was by! LOL.

I feel sorry for David Cook - if what Blake said is true (and why would he not tell the truth), then David got a bad rep because TPTB cut his comment. Daughtry/Live/I Walk The Line all over again.

At least Ryan did acknowledge last night that David C’s version of Billie Jean was a cover of Chris Cornell’s but as far as the Doxology rap, then yeah, you can’t help but feel sorry for him in those regards. It was a shame that this particular part didn’t make it to air.

and boo on tptb for not admitting they cut out doxology’s credit. you can see them NOW reciting the pedigree 7 generations back for every cover being done, but why couldn’t they have just gone back and said, “yeah, David C gave doxology credit, but we decided to edit it out of the video intro…OUR BAD”? anyway I’m glad Blake and my fave this year are cool again :)

It seems that some of the David A fans aren’t satisfied with what he said there. I suppose you can’t please everyone. lol

I am starting to get a bad taste in my mouth when it comes to the Archie fans. They are reminding me too much of other fanatical fan bases of the past, like Claymates or Soul Patrol. If you dare to criticize ANYTHING about Archuleta, they have a complete conniption fit. Plus some of them are very gung-ho to bash other contestants to prop up David A., it’s going to backfire on them if their David is in the final two and they don’t want the other fans voting for whoever is against David.

About Cook, I don’t mind him doing other band’s covers but I’m kinda wanting to hear him do a song straight up close to the original now ;).

So I guess David Cook really did borrow from Doxology? Wow. I’m sorry I doubted their claim now.

I did not doubt DOX from the beginning(They are musicians. There is a reason/conviction for speaking about arrangement. Blake is the same, too). I doubted 19 (I posted it ). Well, I am not surprised at all, but I’m think about Blake is smart that made it clear to be great.

When there was a connection of 19 there, it is difficult to think that similar arrangement happens ‘accidentally’.. Because I was tired. I left it to do it. Because I was tired

Personally, I’m glad he didn’t apologize. Why should he? It’s just an opinion. We all have them. David A is a snoozefest. LOL.

I agree!

Sorta OT: I didn’t watch AI until Season 4, but I’m betting the internet has really changed this competition.

I think so. The Internet affects it.　clearly.

Because I was tired. I left it to do it. Because I was tired

I wanted to comment, but left it.

sorry

I am beginning to feel that we on the internet seem to disect and worry about every little word. While the rest of the US likes there favorite votes and could care less who said what.

Bingo

Also wanted to add; as much as I hate to, all of these interviews and some what controversies do nothing to help OR hurt his sales. Seriously, what he needs his song being played on the radio.

Sigh. Those who rejected Blake’s comments at Ricky are not interested in dialog. Folks got to get over critics.. they must absolutely hate Simon for his comments last night; heh, some probably loathe Randy for his not-so-great talk.

One of the nice things here is that we actually debate Blake’s actions. Blake is not God,, and he surely doesnt want to be an idol.

People will have opinions - make it a challenge for polite discussion and perhaps improvement, not knee-jerk defensiveness.

But for the fans of the people he insulted they’re out of line for thinking he’s a jerk? C’mmon, it’s an opinion . The opinion spin works both ways.

Jaya, you are right. The fans of those he insulted do have a right to their opinion, even if they are wayOTT. I mean wishing the guy ‘ill will’. That is just wrong…IMHO.

I hope the rumors about David A’s dad are false too. Simon’s comment to him last night really got my attention and I’m sure the attention of a lot of folks. If they are really true, then it makes me feel sorry for him too.

Since the Fanjayas & whatever David’s fans are called are obviously carefully analyzing Blake’s every interview, I hope they come across the one in which he says he and Sanjaya are cool now, and the one in which he says he loved David A’s “Imagine” and thought he won the whole thing then and there soon. Also, I’m not sure exactly what Blake said about David’s dad that has everyone in such a tizzy, but consider this: Blake was at Idol just a few weeks ago, so he must have seen something there that disturbed him enough to comment on it. I’d say he probably knows a little more about the situation than the fans do. If I was a fan of David’s, I’d be more alarmed than offended.

As for whether or not the stuff about David’s dad is true? Again, it’s none of Blake’s business to discuss and it’s gossipy. Whether or not papa Archuleta is a crazed stage dad is true or not that’s his and David’s business.

Sorry, but that is wrong. If David is being mistreated and verbally abused, then it’s up to adults on the sidelines both in AI itself and otherwise to stand up for the kid. Saying it’s “his business” is the same as turning a blind eye, and that is not cool.

Arkarch–ITA. Polite challenge to discuss is a great idea. I believe that is what Blake had in mind with his post there, in explanation. I’m sorry that it continues onward with ill-will.

It can be really hard to be nice, when you feel like someone has bashed your favorite. I understand that. I put the shoe on my own foot last night, and I’d be mad too. Heck, I *have* been mad in the past! But I don’t believe Blake (nor Sanjaya or David) would approve or appreciate bashing in their defense. They all seem like peaceful, accepting young men, who just want to get along. I’m thinking of that today.

What does anyone hope to accomplish by bitching anyway? Is Blake supposed to kiss someone’s feet and grovel, begging for forgiveness? Apparently, there is nothing he can do to make up for the “grievous injuries” he’s caused. So, moving on would be the best thing.

But I don’t believe Blake (nor Sanjaya or David) would approve or appreciate bashing in their defense. They all seem like peaceful, accepting young men, who just want to get along.

ITA Bully. And, let’s remember that the majority of the country (and the world) doesn’t post on boards, doesn’t listen to every idol interview, scour the internet, etc.

On a lighter note, I put up a new poll.

I sure hope the drive-bys are clicking on a few google links on their way out!

Short but sweet!

Is anyone else jealous that the haters are getting Blake’s attention? ;o) Blake, show a little love here for your supporters. Just Kidding

Crystal,

That was priceless! I loved it! I think Blake would be proud!

Oh God. More drive-bys

Oh, is that what those are?

Thanks for posting what you did Cyrstal, and Star:)

LOL, Crystal. Blake posted here ONCE and it was very brief.

Short but sweet!

PJ - I remember - I think that was when the album came out? It was very nice, and we all managed to retain our composure. :o)

Just occured to me…..I think we got this blog on his MS page and the post on Rickey as a result of Blake saying the thing about Sanjaya not actually making the show and then the producers putting him back in. I’m without a doubt sure that if that were the case they would NOT want that news out there.

Nah, that info has been out for a while. Sanjaya talks about it in his story in the Idol Chicken Soup book.

Kudos for the blog too-loved the last part and all the ninja talk. :D

His post at Rickey’s may have been an act of PR persuasion, but it still seemed completely genuine. Much like Blake seems.

Why the hell did they cut out DC’s crediting of Doxology? They went through this EXACT SAME situation with Daughtry. You’d think they’d have learned from that.

Sorry, but that is wrong. If David is being mistreated and verbally abused, then it’s up to adults on the sidelines both in AI itself and otherwise to stand up for the kid. Saying it’s “his business” is the same as turning a blind eye, and that is not cool.

Complete and total word to this. Where there’s smoke there’s fire, and I don’t even follow Archie and have read from several places that his dad is a real piece of work. Disgusting, and Blake should say whatever he can about it. People should not just shut up and tolerate the maltreatment of children. I really feel sorry for the kid if this is true.

Let me get this straight. Blake can call David Archuleta boring, insult Sanjaya and bascially spew all sorts of garbage insulting AI and it’s ok because it’s just his opinion, poor Blakey is getting raked over the coals for expressing a little ole opinion. But for the fans of the people he insulted they’re out of line for thinking he’s a jerk?

No, I think the fans of other contestants can be pissed off at Blake if they so choose, they certainly have the freedom to express their displeasure in this society. We don’t live in North Korea or some totalitarian regime devoid of basic human rights.

What I DO have a problem with is the Archuleta and Sanjaya fans freaking out at anything that’s NOT glowing praise for their favorite, and quite a few of the Archuleta fans attacking anyone who does NOT worship at the Archie Altar of Cheesy Music. Plus they are acting like hypocrites, having a meltdown only when THEIR guy gets criticized. But many were not too upset when Constantine trashed most of the Season 7 Idols but ass kissed Archuleta.

Why the hell did they cut out DC’s crediting of Doxology? They went through this EXACT SAME situation with Daughtry. You’d think they’d have learned from that.

Of course they did it by a more unfair method because they learned it.
Please refer to an opinion of MODS, on that day

19 that is good at deceive an audience.
My having thought, “did not said” is not same “didn’t it”. For them, this is an escape way. and And means for it not to let convince(theoretically) of an audience. to use the arrangement of somebody who is not more famous. They are professionals deceiving spectators. but it’s stupid. (Let’s think about the contestant of this year. They repeat the same thing. A thing, the professional, The talent that was already found.)

Bty, I think the scenario of this week to have done it well for DC. A scenario to rule criticism about INCUBUS/DOX. (I mean, judge/Ryan–this is smart scenario. The audience thinks even if they do not mention it, good for DC)

But I’m not sure, All is only my personal opinion.

and more IMO,
I’m not sure, about song choice. He chose or they gave? (
DOX/INCUBUS). I guess, 19. The theme is decided after a contestant selected, Probably. It’s american TV show, They have some scenarios. can realize that they are going to add to DC, something Daughtry/Blake’ flavor

The point that they think to be stupid. I think that should have stolen arrangement of somebody without more connection if I steal arrangement of somebody better They are considerably careless.

Anyway,
I do not understand why he did the post on rickey, I think he do not appear for an excuse. and he used it to show some point. I guess. I think that he knows what kind of site that site is. Why did he leave that he read in the middle of AI? I think that it is not necessary to worry. He used it for a purpose Just my opinion

finally, it not being smart of an argument to advance only by a guess. I think always, then I post now, but I dislike to post/comment this case

—————————————————-

I’d say he probably knows a little more about the situation than the fans do. If I was a fan of David’s, I’d be more alarmed than offended.

I think so too.

Disgusting, and Blake should say whatever he can about it. People should not just shut up and tolerate the maltreatment of children. I really feel sorry for the kid if this is true.

But didn’t a grown man, Blake, shut a kid, Sanjaya, in a closet last year on tour?

I hated hearing about that, and Blake’s recent interview. He’s got to start behaving professionally or his label won’t look kindly on it.

Nice site, you all seem lovely, I adored his dad’s post, and I’ll leave you to it.

Of course they did it by a more unfair method because they learned it.
Please refer to an opinion of MODS, on that day

19 that is good at deceive an audience.
My having thought, “did not said” is not same “didn’t it”. For them, this is an escape way. and And means for it not to let convince(theoretically) of an audience. to use the arrangement of somebody who is not more famous. They are professionals deceiving spectators. but it’s stupid. (Let’s think about the contestant of this year. They repeat the same thing. A thing, the professional, The talent that was already found.)

JPN Fan– When I read your post yesterday, I thought maybe I was mis-understanding what you were getting at, calling 19 deceiving. Here in this post above however? There is no such confusion.

Your remarks suggest you are in fact not such a fan of AI, and of the variety that feel it is all a fake a sham and a set-up.You use words like Unfair, deceiving, and infer they are okie-dokie with stealing from other artists. That last thing I think depends on your personal view regarding Cover-songs anyhow.(see Mods comments on the Doxology issue that topic day, which I thought were very good)

Anyway,
I do not understand why he did the post on rickey, I think he do not appear for an excuse. and he used it to show some point. I guess. I think that he knows what kind of site that site is. Why did he leave that he read in the middle of AI? I think that it is not necessary to worry. He used it for a purpose

The only reason he would have for going to rickey’s and addressing it, was to offer his side in a view that was heating up pretty badly. I don;t think he meant any harm by remarks he said, but now even him being kind enough to address the people’s anger is suspect. I don;t believe he is as calculating as you seem to think.

Prime example of shady behavior - Blake getting stuck with that crap “This Is My Now” and NOT being allowed to re-arrange the song. Could Nigel and his cronies have made it any more obvious that Jordin was their Chosen One, as they put Blake at a ridiculous, unfair disadvantage? That garbage just made me a little more jaded when it comes to this show.

I honestly don’t get what the big deal is about David Cook doing cover songs. This show is basically KARAOKE, as they are NOT allowed to perform their OWN MUSIC. Also, why is it that only the rockers (Daughtry, Cook) get bashed for doing covers? SO MANY contestants do cover versions of songs and no one says shit unless it’s a rock singer, it seems. I can’t remember how many times some screaming diva did a Whitney or Celine spin on some song and no one batted an eyelash when they didn’t give credit to the cover in question. Who cares?

I honestly don’t get what the big deal is about David Cook doing cover songs. This show is basically KARAOKE, as they are NOT allowed to perform their OWN MUSIC. Also, why is it that only the rockers (Daughtry, Cook) get bashed for doing covers?

ITA. It doesn;t seem fair that people say “well it wasn;t THAT good, it was a cover of (fill in the blank group)”. Heard that phenomenon on the radio yesterday, when the DJ played it, blown away by D Cook only to have a woman call in and wryly say,”Well, it was a COPY of Chris Cornell’s.” The DJ says with disbelief, “Really?? How do you know this?” and she says, “I own the Chris Cornell CD”. It all of a sudden was like not a big deal, the way he performed that. I think that is really unfair.
It is a karaoke show. It is a show of COVERS. I think it’s good to give the artist who rearranged it credit, but honestly, they shouldn;t take away the awesome opinion of a job well done just because it is a cover.IMO. I think D Cook has done a great job the last few weeks, and if that makes the rocker guy a one trick pony? Well so be it. It’s still great.

I know what you mean about TIMN, and not being able to rearrange it– it’s like they were afraid it would give Blake an advantage, god forbid. Personally, I’dve liked to hear what he could have done with it, properly motivated! hah!

I dislike that this show deceives an audience intentionally simply. Even if it did not say that he arranged it, let an audience misunderstanding intentionally. This show is not about arrangement, but emphasized it in the past. then… why they did that day. It is added value.
(and this show is not about ‘risk taking’, It is added value, too)

Oh, anyway. I think that he can show own something just to sing/performance. If a producer believes it, I think that they always should clarify an original arrangement. If he does not have added value, so be it. It is not necessary. That’s all. just my opinio.

I yet felt nothing in his sing/performance. My evaluation standard always has nothing to do with arrangement/risk taking. and of course, I know that he is a good singer. However, unfortunately I do not yet feel something which is special to him. This is a fact for me. it’s not same, ‘dislike’ and ‘felt nothing’. OK? I’m not DC hater.

(Btw, Even if I am not fan of the show, I had felt something to the person of other, till now. in past season.　Of course, Regardless of my liking the person, feel it not reason.)

Oh, anyway, I have to go. because my English sucks it in.

PS-That days Mods comments, It was a paradoxical meaning that referred to it. The method that a show deceived. However, probably this will not go I mean …

—I think that nobody reads, but just post this.